Yes, Mafia: The Old Country is worth it if you want a tight, story-first crime game and you are happy to be led, which is the question I kept circling while I played, because the best thing this one can do for you is end. It is the newest entry in the Mafia series, made by Hangar 13, and it is a linear, story-driven crime game set in Sicily, so it is not a GTA-shaped sandbox where you mess about for forty hours before you touch the plot. It is a tight, authored experience that wants to tell you a specific story, at a specific pace, and then get out of your way, and everything else I think about it flows from that choice.
Sicily, which is the first thing that grabbed me
Sicily is a smart, confident choice, because instead of yet another sprawling mid-century American city you get cypress trees, dusty roads, sulphur mines and stone villages, along with the series’ usual fascination with honour, loyalty and the cost of both. It looks the part and, more importantly, it feels the part, since this is a place with a mood rather than a map to fill with icons, and I noticed the roads before I noticed the mission markers, which is not how these games usually introduce themselves.
Linear on purpose, which is the feature
I realise “it is quite linear” reads like a criticism in 2026, when half the industry measures value in square kilometres, and I do not see it that way, because a focused story means the pacing actually holds and scenes land when the game controls when they happen. There is no thirty-minute drive across an empty county to dilute a tense moment, so if you have ever bounced off a huge open world because the main thread drowned in busywork, this restraint will feel like a relief rather than a limitation. I have bounced off those counties myself, usually while telling myself the drive was the game, and it is pleasant to be wrong about that for once.
The short run, and the Free Ride that is not the meal
If your idea of value is raw hours and total freedom, The Old Country will feel short and a little on-rails, because you are following a story rather than authoring your own chaos, and I would rather put that on the table than discover it in your refund request. There is a free Free Ride mode for open-ended pottering about once you have worked through the campaign, which is a nice touch and gives the world some legs after the credits, though it is a bonus rather than the main event. Buy it for the story and treat the rest as dessert, because a living sandbox is a different appetite, and the portion is fair if you came hungry for the plot and disappointing if you came hungry for the map.
Man of Honor, and who should still buy it
A story expansion called Man of Honor has been announced for the game, which tells you the team intend to keep building on this world rather than abandoning it the moment it shipped. I am not going to oversell what it adds, because I would rather you judge that when it actually lands. It is a fair signal that the story is not a one-and-done, which matters if longevity is the worry that has been sitting next to the word short. For my kind of player, yes, comfortably, because this sits right in my solo-narrative wheelhouse, the same shelf as the rest of my Mafia coverage, slow-burn crime stories I take my time with rather than rush through.
If you want a tight, beautifully made, story-first crime game and you are happy to be led, this is exactly the kind of thing I keep asking the big studios to make more of. If you specifically want freedom and sheer scale, be honest with yourself and look elsewhere, because no amount of Sicilian atmosphere turns this into a sandbox. The wider context, meaning all my Mafia runs and slow-burn crime coverage, lives on the WillyB Mafia hub. If it turns out you actually do crave the big open map, I keep a separate list of the best open world games to play solo, which is where I send anyone who wants to wander rather than be led.
FAQ
Is Mafia: The Old Country worth it?
Yes, if you want a tight, story-first crime game and you are happy to be led, because it sits in the solo-narrative wheelhouse of a slow-burn crime story rather than a sandbox you mess about in for forty hours before you touch the plot. If you want freedom and sheer scale, the Sicilian atmosphere will not turn it into one, and I would rather say that before you buy it.
Is Mafia: The Old Country open world?
No, it is a linear, story-driven game set in Sicily, and there is a free Free Ride mode for open-ended pottering once you finish the campaign, though that mode is a bonus rather than the main event. Buy it for the story, and treat the wandering afterwards as dessert, because the campaign is the thing Hangar 13 actually authored.
Who should avoid Mafia: The Old Country?
If your idea of value is raw hours and total freedom, it will feel short and a little on-rails, because it is built for the story rather than for authoring your own chaos. I like that restraint, and I also know it will read as a missing map to anyone who measures a crime game in square kilometres.
Where is Mafia: The Old Country set?
Sicily, and it is a smart, confident choice, because instead of another mid-century American city you get cypress trees, dusty roads, sulphur mines and stone villages, with the series' usual fascination with honour and loyalty and the cost of both. It looks the part, and more importantly it feels like a place with a mood rather than a map waiting for icons.
Who made Mafia: The Old Country?
Hangar 13, the studio behind the series, and it is the newest entry in the Mafia line, a linear crime story they wanted told at a specific pace before they got out of the way. I have been asking the big studios for more of this shelf, and this is one of the times they actually put one there.
Is there more content coming to Mafia: The Old Country?
Yes, a story expansion called Man of Honor has been announced, which signals the team intend to keep building on this world rather than abandoning it the moment it shipped. I am not going to oversell what it adds, because I would rather you judge that when it actually lands, and the signal is fair even before the hours are.
More like this
MafiaMafia The Old Country: Man of Honor DLC Release Date
Man of Honor was announced at Summer Game Fest and lands on 14 August, with two new chapters following Enzo in winter 1905, the return of Ennio Salieri from the original Mafia, and a wider Free Ride, though I have not played it and I will not call it worth the tenner until I have.7 Jun 2026Read
STALKER 2Is STALKER 2 Cost of Hope Worth It?
Yes, if you already like the Zone, because Cost of Hope is the paid story expansion that landed with free Update 2.0 on 20 August, and I treated it as free roam rather than a campaign recap, so you buy it for Iron Forest and the plant and you skip it if you only wanted the free patch.25 Aug 2026ReadNew field reports, to your inbox
No spam. Leave whenever you like.